Why HP should withdtaw its ad on last minute projects

I saw the HP Ink Advantage ad and I felt something was not right. As I saw it more times I felt that there were several things not right about it. HP should withdraw it in the interest of our school going children so that they do not think that it is ok not to sincerely work on a project assignment if you have money to buy a printer. Here are the things not right:

1. The mother seems proud and even happy when she says that everything happens at the last minute: She is dressed in western clothes, her house appears financially well-off. And she seems to be approving of everything happening at the last moment. Is she educated? Did she and her husband make this much money doing everything at the last moment? What has she been doing all the while when the kids were developing the habit of doing everything at the last minute? If she knows that ‘it is hard to do good things in a rush’, what is the solution? Change the habit of doing things at the last minute – in the interest of her children and their future colleagues – or approve of it and buy a printer at home??

2. The project is done by the whole family and not the laggard boy: Is that how his school is expecting him to learn (if at all)? The schools assign projects to students so that they learn by doing. As if doing the project at the last moment is not bad enough, this ad gives a false impression to children about the value of self learning.

3. The ‘last moment’ project gets an A+: Another bad, bad signal to growing children – that unlike other students, who might have planned their projects, worked on it for days ahead of the deadline, the laggard gets an A+. I wonder why. Snazzy printing? Are the judges fools? Or is the teacher that assigns such projects that can be done in a jiffy if you can afford a printer at home?

4. The students who watch this ad but cannot afford to buy the printer have nowhere to go: Are projects prized for their glamor? Is glamor a make up that can be patched up before going on to a stage? What if you are one of the students whose parents cannot afford to buy a printer at home?

By the way, if you have not watched the ad, it is here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v-LQ8FEAiyM

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “Why HP should withdtaw its ad on last minute projects

  1. Kshema says:

    Well observed and well written post. I agree with your views. There are more such misleading ads like Windows 8 PC that can find a better match, better jobs and also can teach the teacher etc. We are expected to believe technology is driving us and India is shining! 😉

    Like

  2. rkpurohit says:

    … and who says we don’t plan or don’t plan early?

    we do plan and plan early, we just act late.

    If we Indians are not a planning civilization, for what does the world think, we had so many 5-year-PLANS ? 🙂

    Like

  3. rkpurohit says:

    I tried to explore other side of the article (knowing the risk that you may slap me for that, 😀 )…

    just for fun…

    1) mom is happy with “last minute thing” because she always have time for other things before anyone shows up with a last minute alarm

    2) if someone is stuck, as a family, you get him/her out together and get the things done.

    3) it shows that if a work is done together with unity, with good intensions and full attention, even a last minute flick can get you an A+

    4) The (family of the )students that can afford the fees of the kind of school (shown in the ad) in a metro, can also afford a printer.
    by the way, printer is always cheaper than ink, in total. 😉

    (you can read and delete if it is not fit to be published, sorry and thanks)

    Like

  4. rkpurohit says:

    Yes ma’am, it’s a serious point you have raised and I agree with you that printers (or any gadget, for that matter) cannot gurantee grades or neither they are really needed to be knowledgable.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s